[she's nodding along because this all makes complete sense until suddenly it does not. hold on. hold the fuck up.]

Our souls already belonged to the cultists? How's that possible when we're still alive and the sacrificial ritual hasn't started yet? I guess maybe he wouldn't really know, huh. [she says, mostly because she isn't sure they would've had time to ask and to save you from having to answer if there's no answer.]

Then again it could just be because we're stuck here. But if it worked in the end maybe we can't worry about that too much either.